Skip to main content
Back to BlogPersonal Injury

MedPay vs Health Insurance in Arizona: What You Need to Know

Gil Hacohen October 13, 2026 10 min read
I'm Gil Hacohen, a Phoenix attorney and founder of Lawyers For Less. When someone is injured or facing a legal problem they did not choose, they may find themselves dealing with serious consequences, mounting expenses, lost income, and an insurance company or opposing party determined to minimize its responsibility. I believe people deserve an attorney who will take the time to understand their situation, investigate what actually happened, and challenge the other side's version of events when the evidence tells a different story. My job is to protect my clients' interests, hold responsible parties accountable, and pursue the outcome they deserve.
Gil Hacohen, Esq.|State Bar of Arizona No. 031934

MedPay and health insurance both cover medical expenses after a car accident. MedPay (medical payments coverage) is a type of auto insurance that pays medical costs regardless of who is at fault. Health insurance, but, covers a broader range of medical needs but may have network restrictions and deductibles.

Key Takeaways

  • MedPay is optional in Arizona and covers accident-related medical expenses.
  • Health insurance may have higher deductibles and network limitations.
  • MedPay can help avoid hospital liens by covering immediate costs.
  • Subrogation rights affect reimbursement from insurance settlements.
  • Carrying both types of insurance provides complete financial protection.

Opting for both MedPay and health insurance ensures that you have multiple layers of protection, greatly reducing financial stress in the aftermath of an accident. It's wise to assess the coverage limits and stipulations of both your health insurance and MedPay to fully understand the benefits they offer.

What is MedPay and How Does it Work in Arizona?

MedPay is optional auto insurance that covers medical expenses after an accident, regardless of fault. It is distinct from liability insurance, which covers damages you cause to others.

Definition and Coverage Limits

MedPay covers medical expenses such as ambulance fees, hospital stays, and surgical costs. Coverage limits vary by policy, often ranging from $1,000 to $10,000. It's important to review your policy to understand these limits. Some insurers may offer higher limits, allowing you to choose a policy that best suits your needs. This flexibility can be particularly beneficial if you frequently drive with passengers or have a high-deductible health insurance plan.

Eligibility and Optional Nature

In Arizona, MedPay is not mandatory. Drivers can choose to add it to their auto insurance policy for additional protection. This option can be particularly beneficial for those without complete health insurance or high deductibles. It's also useful for drivers who want immediate access to funds for medical expenses without waiting for health insurance claims to process. MedPay can be a lifesaver for those who want to avoid the red tape often associated with health insurance claims, providing a straightforward way to manage medical costs following an accident.

How Does Health Insurance Handle Car Accident Injuries?

Health insurance covers medical costs, including those from car accidents, but its coverage may be limited by network restrictions and deductibles.

Coverage and Limitations

Health insurance typically covers a wide range of medical services. But, you may need to meet a deductible before the insurance pays. Also, some treatments may not be covered if they are outside your network. It's essential to understand your plan's specifics, as emergency services are often covered regardless of network status, but follow-up treatments may not be. Knowing these limitations can prevent unexpected bills and make sure you get the necessary care without financial strain.

Network Restrictions and Deductibles

Health plans often require using network providers to receive full benefits. If you use out-of-network services, you may face higher costs. Deductibles must be met annually, impacting out-of-pocket expenses. It's advisable to verify whether your preferred medical providers are in-network before receiving treatment. On top of that, understanding your annual deductible can help you plan for potential out-of-pocket expenses, ensuring you're financially prepared for any additional costs.

Differences Between MedPay and Health Insurance

MedPay and health insurance both cover medical expenses but differ in scope and speed of payment.

Coverage Scope and Speed of Payment

MedPay pays quickly, covering costs as soon as claims are filed, without waiting for fault determination. Health insurance processes can be slower, particularly if determining liability is complex. This immediate access to funds can be important in emergencies, allowing you to focus on recovery instead of financial concerns. Conversely, health insurance might require multiple interactions with insurers, delaying payments and adding stress during an already challenging time.

Cost Implications and Out-of-Pocket Expenses

MedPay can reduce out-of-pocket expenses immediately after an accident. Health insurance may involve co-pays and deductibles, which can be substantial depending on your policy. The quick payments from MedPay can alleviate the initial financial burden, ensuring that medical providers are compensated promptly, which can also prevent the accrual of interest on unpaid medical bills. Health insurance, while complete, might require you to manage co-payments and coinsurance, potentially increasing your financial responsibilities.

Which Coverage Should You Use First After an Accident?

Choosing between MedPay and health insurance first depends on your specific situation.

Strategic Use of MedPay

Use MedPay to cover immediate medical expenses, especially if your health insurance deductible is high. This strategy can minimize financial strain after an accident. By paying upfront costs through MedPay, you can keep your health insurance for more extensive or long-term treatments, maximizing your benefits across both types of coverage. This approach ensures that you aren't caught off guard by unexpected out-of-pocket expenses.

Avoiding Hospital Liens

In Arizona, hospitals may place liens on settlements to recover treatment costs. Using MedPay can prevent liens by paying expenses upfront. Under A.R.S. § 33-931, liens are common, but MedPay helps avoid them. It is essential to inform the hospital of your MedPay coverage early in the treatment process to make sure they bill the appropriate insurer and avoid placing a lien on your potential settlement. This before problems arise approach can save significant time and financial resources in the long run.

The Role of Subrogation in MedPay and Health Insurance

Subrogation involves an insurer seeking reimbursement from a liable party for claims paid.

Understanding Subrogation Rights

Both MedPay and health insurance may seek subrogation, impacting your settlement recovery. MedPay often doesn't pursue subrogation, allowing your settlement to remain unaffected. But, health insurance, especially plans governed by ERISA, may aggressively pursue subrogation, which can complicate settlements. Understanding these rights is important, as they can significantly influence your final compensation after an accident, potentially reducing your net recovery.

ERISA and Its Impact

Employer-provided health insurance under ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act) can have strong subrogation rights, potentially affecting settlement amounts. ERISA plans often have rigorous subrogation clauses, mandating reimbursement from any settlement received. This can be particularly challenging if your settlement is intended to cover non-medical damages, such as pain and suffering. Consulting with a legal professional can help handle these complexities, ensuring your rights are protected.

Benefits of Carrying MedPay in Arizona

MedPay provides financial protection and peace of mind by covering immediate medical expenses without deductible concerns.

Financial Protection and Peace of Mind

MedPay ensures quick coverage of medical costs, reducing stress after an accident. It provides security, especially if other insurance options involve high deductibles or co-pays. Many drivers appreciate the straightforward nature of MedPay, as it simplifies the claims process and provides immediate assistance when it's most needed. This peace of mind can be invaluable during recovery, allowing you to focus entirely on your health rather than financial worries.

Common Misconceptions About MedPay

Misunderstandings about MedPay can lead to underutilization of this beneficial coverage.

Myths vs. Reality

A common myth is that MedPay duplicates health insurance. But, MedPay provides immediate payment and covers costs that health insurance might not, such as deductibles and co-pays. Also, some assume MedPay is unnecessary if they have good health insurance, but the quick access to funds and coverage of out-of-pocket expenses can prove invaluable. Understanding the specific benefits of MedPay can help maximize your financial protection.

Arizona Statutes Governing MedPay and Health Insurance

Several Arizona statutes regulate insurance practices, ensuring consumer protection.

Relevant A.R.S. Sections

Under A.R.S. § 20-259.01, insurers must offer MedPay as an option. This statute ensures consumers are informed about their choices and coverage specifics. Familiarizing yourself with these statutes can help you to make informed decisions about your insurance coverage, in the end ensuring you are adequately protected in the event of an accident.

FAQs About MedPay and Health Insurance in Arizona

What is the difference between MedPay and PIP?

MedPay and PIP (Personal Injury Protection) both cover medical expenses, but PIP includes additional benefits like lost wages. Arizona does not require PIP, making MedPay a common choice. MedPay focuses solely on medical costs, while PIP offers more full coverage, including rehabilitation and substitution benefits. Understanding these distinctions can help you choose the right coverage based on your needs.

How does MedPay affect my insurance premium?

Adding MedPay increases your auto insurance premium slightly, but it provides valuable coverage for accident-related costs. The increment in premiums is usually minimal compared to the potential benefits and peace of mind it offers. Evaluating your budget and potential out-of-pocket expenses can help determine if the additional cost is a worthwhile investment.

When should I use MedPay instead of health insurance?

Use MedPay to immediately cover out-of-pocket expenses and avoid hospital liens, especially if you have a high deductible health plan. This approach can prevent financial strain and make sure timely payment of medical bills, reducing the risk of credit issues or additional interest on unpaid medical expenses. Strategic use of MedPay can also preserve your health insurance benefits for complete or long-term treatments.

Can MedPay be used for passengers in my car?

Yes, MedPay covers medical expenses for passengers injured in your vehicle during an accident, providing broader protection. This feature offers peace of mind when driving with others, ensuring that everyone in the vehicle has immediate access to medical coverage if needed. It's important to communicate this benefit to any passengers, so they are aware of their options in case of an accident.

Does MedPay cover lost wages?

MedPay typically does not cover lost wages. It's designed to cover medical expenses only. For income protection, other types of insurance or legal avenues might be needed, such as disability insurance or pursuing damages through a personal injury claim. Evaluating your overall risk and insurance needs can help you determine if additional coverage is necessary.

How do hospital liens work in Arizona?

Hospitals may file liens on settlements to recover treatment costs, as outlined in A.R.S. § 33-931. Using MedPay can help avoid these liens by paying expenses upfront. It's essential to inform hospitals of your MedPay coverage early in the treatment process to prevent them from filing a lien, ensuring a smoother settlement process. Understanding and addressing liens proactively can save you significant time and financial resources.

When to Hire a Lawyer for Insurance Claims

Knowing when to involve a lawyer can protect your rights and maximize compensation.

Signs You Need Legal Assistance

Consider hiring a lawyer if your insurance claim is denied, delayed, or if subrogation issues arise. Lawyers can handle complex insurance regulations and make sure fair treatment. They can also provide valuable insights into negotiating settlements, ensuring you receive the compensation you're entitled to. Legal expertise is especially beneficial in disputes involving multiple insurance policies or when facing aggressive subrogation claims.

How Lawyers Can Help

Our attorneys at Lawyers For Less regularly handle insurance claims and can provide expert guidance through the process. For more information, contact us for a free consultation. By leveraging their experience, you can manage the complexities of insurance claims with confidence, ensuring that your rights are protected and your compensation is maximized. Lawyers can also handle communication with insurers, allowing you to focus on recovery.

For further assistance and to learn more about your options, contact Lawyers For Less at (602) 800-5762 or visit our contact page to schedule a free consultation.

Gil Hacohen, Founder and Principal Attorney, Lawyers For Less, PLLC

Gil Hacohen, Esq.

Founder and Principal Attorney, Lawyers For Less, PLLC

State Bar of Arizona No. 031934

Licensed in Arizona since 2015

About Our Phoenix Attorney, Gil Hacohen

Gil Hacohen is the founder and principal attorney of Lawyers For Less, PLLC, a Phoenix-based law firm representing individuals and families throughout Arizona. Licensed to practice law in Arizona since 2015, Gil handles personal injury claims involving commercial trucks, delivery vehicles, and other motor vehicle collisions, including cases involving disputed liability, significant injuries, and complex insurance claims, as well as criminal defense, family law, estate planning and business formation matters. He combines hands-on legal representation with a commitment to making quality legal services accessible to everyday people.

Why I do this work

I founded Lawyers For Less in 2015 because I believed that access to quality legal representation should not depend on someone's financial resources. I wanted to build a practice where clients could receive experienced, personalized representation without feeling lost in the legal system.

That philosophy is especially important when the other side has more resources. When someone is seriously injured, charged with a crime, or going through a divorce, they may suddenly find themselves facing an insurance carrier, a prosecutor, or a legal process they don't understand. I believe my clients deserve an attorney who listens to their concerns, carefully examines the evidence, and isn't afraid to challenge the other side's conclusions.

Quick Inquiry

Get a free consultation today

Free consultation • No obligation • Confidential

Need Legal Help?

Need help with personal injury?

Learn About Our Personal Injury Services →
Free Case Evaluation

Ready to Get the Legal
Help You Deserve?

Schedule your free consultation today. No obligation, no pressure — just honest legal advice at a price you can afford.

Available Mon-Fri 8AM-6PM, Sat 9AM-1PM. Emergency consultations available.

More